Ben Powers Represents Calvin Atchison in Murder Case Dismissed After Years of Legal Proceedings

NewsChannel 5 Reports on Dismissal of First-Degree Murder Charge Against Legal Powers Client

A first-degree murder charge against Calvin Atchison was dismissed in July 2026, ending a prosecution tied to the decades-old killing of Velma Tharpe in North Nashville.

Tennessee criminal defense attorney Ben Powers represented Atchison, who had been charged in 2021 with Tharpe’s 2000 murder. The case had an unusually complicated history. Another man, Paul Garrett, had previously pleaded guilty to voluntary manslaughter in connection with Tharpe’s death before his conviction was later vacated.

Atchison’s case continued for several years before a special prosecutor ultimately determined the state could not prove the charge beyond a reasonable doubt.

Following the dismissal, Powers told NewsChannel 5 that the defense had maintained Atchison’s innocence throughout the case.

Read NewsChannel 5’s coverage of the dismissal.

How Did Calvin Atchison Become a Defendant in the Case?

Velma Tharpe was found dead in a North Nashville alley in June 2000. Paul Garrett was initially prosecuted in connection with her death and pleaded guilty to voluntary manslaughter in 2003.

Years later, the case took a dramatic turn.

Using questionable interpretations of the evidence in the case file, cold case investigators encouraged the District Attorney’s Office to vacate the Garrett’s conviction, and Garrett’s conviction was vacated in 2021.

That same year, Atchison was arrested and charged with first-degree murder in Tharpe’s death. Powers represented Atchison against the murder charge that followed the renewed investigation.

What Happened After Ben Powers Took on Atchison’s Defense?

Powers challenged the state’s case against Atchison as the prosecution moved toward trial.

NewsChannel 5 previously reported that Powers questioned the strength of the evidence during an August 2021 bond hearing. He pressed a Metro Nashville cold case detective about whether investigators had developed new evidence against Atchison beyond the DNA evidence that had been known for years.

The case later became entangled in a separate controversy involving the Davidson County District Attorney’s Office.

In 2024, a joint investigation by the Tennessee Bureau of Investigation and the Tennessee Comptroller’s Office found that criminal defense attorneys had been recorded without their knowledge while reviewing evidence inside the DA’s office. Powers and a private investigator working on Atchison’s defense were among those captured by the recording system while reviewing evidence and discussing the case.

Powers filed a motion seeking to disqualify the Davidson County District Attorney’s Office from prosecuting Atchison. The trial was postponed, and District Attorney Glenn Funk later stepped aside from the case. A special prosecutor was appointed to take over the prosecution.

Why Was the Murder Charge Against Calvin Atchison Dismissed?

After reviewing the case, the special prosecutor moved to dismiss the first-degree murder charge against Atchison in July 2026.

According to reporting on the dismissal, the prosecutor determined that the state could not meet its burden of proving the case beyond a reasonable doubt.

The dismissal ended a prosecution against Atchison that had been pending for more than five years.

Powers told NewsChannel 5 following the decision, “We’ve always known that Calvin was innocent.”

The dismissal ended the criminal prosecution of Atchison because the state determined it could not prove its case beyond a reasonable doubt.

A Case Spanning More Than Two Decades

The dismissal marked another major development in a criminal case that had moved through the Nashville court system in different forms for more than two decades.

Prosecutors first charged Garrett, who served years in prison before his conviction was vacated. Atchison was subsequently charged with the same killing, beginning a separate prosecution that lasted from 2021 until the charge was dismissed in 2026.

For Powers and the defense, the July 2026 decision ended that prosecution after years of challenging the case against Atchison.

Read the full NewsChannel 5 report on the dismissal and the history of the case.

Experienced Tennessee Criminal Defense Representation

Serious criminal cases can involve years of investigation, disputed evidence, changing prosecutors, and extensive litigation before they reach a resolution. Ben Powers represented Calvin Atchison throughout a first-degree murder prosecution that ultimately ended with the state dismissing the charge.

Legal Powers PLLC represents people facing serious criminal charges throughout Tennessee. The firm carefully examines the evidence against its clients, challenges the prosecution when appropriate, and protects clients’ rights throughout the criminal process.

If you or a loved one is facing serious criminal charges in Tennessee, send an online message or call (615) 762-8775 to discuss your case.

Start here - Ask us anything