Overview of Negligent Homicide in Tennessee

A fatal accident can become a felony investigation before anyone has time to process what happened. A firearm left within reach, unsafe conduct around another person, or a serious lapse in judgment may lead investigators to ask whether the risk was obvious.

Criminally negligent homicide in Tennessee requires more than ordinary carelessness. It is a Class E felony based on criminal negligence causing another person’s death. Our experienced Tennessee homicide defense attorneys at Legal Powers PLLC examine whether the evidence meets this criminal standard.

Please don’t hesitate to give us a call at (615) 762-8775 or submit the online form today for a free consultation.

What Is Criminally Negligent Homicide Under Tennessee Law?

Tennessee treats criminal homicide as the unlawful killing of another person. Criminally negligent homicide is one form of criminal homicide, and the offense occurs when criminally negligent conduct results in another person’s death.

What is negligent homicide? The difficult part is understanding criminal negligence. A person acts with criminal negligence when they should be aware of a substantial and unjustifiable risk that a circumstance exists or a result will occur. Failing to recognize that risk must be a gross deviation from the care an ordinary person would exercise under the circumstances.

Prosecutors do not have to prove intent to kill, but they must prove substantially more than an ordinary mistake or lapse in care. Reckless homicide depends on awareness and conscious disregard of a risk, while criminal negligence focuses on a risk the person should have perceived.

What Must the State Prove Beyond a Reasonable Doubt?

A criminally negligent homicide prosecution in Tennessee requires the State to prove three things beyond a reasonable doubt:

  • Criminally negligent conduct. The accused should have perceived a substantial and unjustifiable risk, and failing to perceive it represented a gross departure from ordinary care.
  • A death. Another person must have died.
  • Causation. The conduct must have proximately caused the death, meaning the death must have been a natural and probable result of the conduct.

The state must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the accused’s legally negligent conduct was the immediate and proximate cause of the death involved in the allegation.

Ordinary negligence is not enough. A gross deviation requires more than inattention, inadvertence, or a simple failure to use reasonable care.

Is Negligent Homicide a Felony in Tennessee?

Yes, criminally negligent homicide is a Class E offense, carrying one to six years in prison and a fine of up to $3,000.

The applicable range depends in part on the person’s criminal history and statutory offender classification:

  • Range I is one to two years,
  • Range II is two to four years, and
  • Range III is four to six years.

For people researching penalties for negligent homicidein Tennessee, the determination of criminal negligence occurs before sentencing.

What Can Criminal Negligence Look Like in a Real Tennessee Case?

Court decisions show why the details matter and why not every fatal accident qualifies.

In State v. Briggs, the Court of Criminal Appeals reversed a conviction from a fatal interstate crash. The defendant was driving slowly with hazard lights after a blown tire, and the court concluded the evidence showed, at most, a failure to use due care rather than the gross deviation criminal negligence requires.

But in State v. Goodwin, the defendant left a cocked, loaded shotgun in overgrown woods about 50 feet behind a home where children were present. Two children found the gun, and it discharged, killing one of them. The Tennessee Supreme Court upheld the criminally negligent homicide conviction, finding that the defendant should have recognized the substantial risk of leaving the firearm there.

These cases do not create automatic rules for guns or vehicles. They illustrate the central question: how serious was the risk and should the accused person have recognized it?

Where Can the Defense Challenge the State’s Criminal-Negligence Theory?

A knowledgeable and skilled defense tests every link between the alleged conduct, the claimed risk, and the death.

Important issues may include:

  • The level of risk. Was the danger truly substantial and unjustifiable, or is the prosecution treating ordinary carelessness as criminal?
  • What the accused should have perceived. The law considers the circumstances from the accused’s standpoint, not just with hindsight after someone died.
  • Causation. Medical evidence, another person’s actions, a mechanical problem, or an intervening event may affect whether the accused’s conduct legally caused the death.
  • The reliability of the evidence. Witness accounts, video, scene evidence, firearm testing, medical findings, and digital records may change how the event should be understood.

The defense is not limited to saying the death was accidental. The key question is whether the evidence proves criminal negligence and causation beyond a reasonable doubt.

How Does Legal Powers Separate Hindsight from Criminal Negligence?

Legal Powers PLLC brings prosecution, courtroom, and defense perspectives to serious felony cases throughout Franklin, Nashville, Williamson County, Rutherford County, and Middle Tennessee.

If investigators claim an improperly stored firearm created the fatal risk, we may examine who had access, the surrounding circumstances, what risk the accused should have perceived, the forensic evidence, and the sequence leading to the discharge.

If the allegation arises from a crash, equipment failure, or another accident, we may examine evidence from the scene, mechanical issues, witness accounts, and medical causation before accepting the prosecution’s explanation.

That is how we test whether hindsight is substituted for proof.

Facing a Criminally Negligent Homicide Tennessee Charge? Start with the Evidence, Not the Label

A death makes any criminal case emotionally difficult, but the State must still prove every element of the charged offense. Legal Powers PLLC can examine the alleged risk, causation, forensic evidence, and circumstances before important decisions are made.

Contact us online or call (615) 762-8775 to discuss the charge and what the evidence may mean for your defense. We offer free, no-obligation consultations.

FAQs About Criminally Negligent Homicide in Tennessee

Can the Actions of the Person Who Died Affect the Case?

Yes, but their conduct does not automatically defeat the charge. The Tennessee Supreme Court has held that a deceased person’s contributing negligence may matter to causation, but it is not a complete defense by itself.

Is Attempted Criminally Negligent Homicide a Tennessee Crime?

No. Tennessee appellate authority recognizes that attempted criminally negligent homicide is not an offense because an attempt requires intent, while criminal negligence is based on failing to perceive a risk.

Can Criminally Negligent Homicide Be a Lesser Charge in a More Serious Homicide Case?

Yes. In State v. Buchanan, a Rutherford County jury convicted the defendant of criminally negligent homicide as a lesser-included offense of felony murder. Whether that instruction or verdict is available depends on the charged offense and the evidence.

Legal References Used to Inform This Page

To ensure the accuracy and clarity of this page, we referenced official legal and other resources during the content development process:

Leave a Comment

Start here - Ask us anything